“If baking a cake for a gay wedding means you support gay marriage, then helping a pedophile get elected in Alabama means you support pedophilia.” – Scott Nevins
The logic is sound. The statement pointed and poignant. This is the world we live in and it is not pretty or easy to swallow. With no facetiousness intended, the idiom that “you can’t have your cake and eat it too” seems àpropos here. This is not a new debate and I know that by writing this I will potentially open the door to all kinds of political diatribe and the temptation to take “sides” in this imagined “culture” war so many believe us to be fighting. Please forgive me – I do not intend anything here to be an endorsement of, or slander towards, any political party or candidate – that is not the issue at hand. The problem presented is the absolute cognitive dissonance that so many Christians have fallen into, the moral irrelevancy, and the presentation of a “Christianity” that is absolutely devoid of the Christ, inconsistent, and utterly meaningless. It has very much become a club for the chosen, a haven for the holy, and a menagerie for members only.
Yes, I have been and will continue to be “harsh” on the “church”, and I know what I write here often sounds condemning and critical and perhaps even seems as if I’m saying I no longer believe in or want to be a part of the very institution I call my home. That is not my intent. The church is full of hypocrites; how could it be otherwise? It includes me. I am a part of the hypocrisy. I know this and accept fully that I have helped to create the problem. I am not soft on sin; I am generous on grace. However I am at a point, as one of my favorite singer/songwriters David Bazaan says in his song, “Level With Yourself”, finding myself reflecting on what it all means. Like someone who’s woken from a long nap, and knows that they are no longer asleep and dreaming, I want to deal with the real…with the now. What I am asking, is for all of us who identify as “Christians” or “the Church”, etc., to do a FULL STOP, and consider our calling, our consistency, and what things like cake and political candidates have to do with any of it?!?! When the world around us associates the word Christian with anti-gay, anti-abortion, and bigotry and all things that we are seemingly AGAINST more than loving, pro ALL life, welcoming to everyone, and what we are FOR, we must stop and consider what we are doing. As Rich Mullins once said, “All I ask of anybody is that you make a little effort to be consistent.” What are we doing? Perhaps we ought to level with ourselves…we have failed in so many ways to be the real thing and have become a shadow of the real.
Clericalism suffocates; it makes part of itself into the whole sacred character of the Church; it makes its power a sacred power to control, to lead, to administer; a power to perform sacraments, and, in general, it makes any power a power given to me! Clericalism separates all “sacredness” from the lay people: the iconostasis, communion (only by permission), theology. In short, clericalism is de facto denial of the Church as the body of Christ, for in the body, all organs are related and different only in their functions, but not in their essence. And the more clericalism clericalizes (the traditional image of the bishop or the priest emphasized by his clothes, hair, e.g., the bishop in full regalia!) the more the Church itself becomes more worldly; spiritually submits itself to this world. In the New Testament, the priest is presented as the ideal layman. But almost immediately there begins his increasingly radical separation from the lay people; and not only separation, but opposition to lay people, contrast to them. – Fr. Alexander Schmemann [Journals, pp. 310 & 311]
Redux. The time has come to say more about the problem of clericalism in the church. Nearly 7 years ago I wrote a post entitled “Shepherds or Butchers?” The post title comes from this short story, told by Fr. Tom Hopko.
“Clericalism: A policy of maintaining or increasing the power of a religious hierarchy.”
It is a problem. Nay, it is a BIG problem. Since writing that first post several years ago, I am now 7 years older and 7 more years “woke” to things I was not awake to 7 years ago. Over these past years, I’ve become increasingly more concerned as I have witnessed a steady trend towards more clericalism within the Church. It is like a cancer that is silently growing.
“The truth is like a lion; you don’t need to defend it. Let it loose; it will defend itself.” – Augustine of Hippo
Perhaps we live in troubled times, and perhaps things are just as they’ve always been and I’m just noticing more. I don’t know which is the case, but I do know that most days I find myself baffled, bewildered, beat down, bedraggled, and overwhelmed with sorrow at all that I see in the news and in the world around me. The violence and sadness that top the news feed, as well as the loss of incredible musicians in the past two weeks, and so many more this past year, combined with the loss of dear friends to depression, disease, and simply old age and bodies wearing out, have me often considering the point of this mortal coil. Musicians and poets can give words to our emotions when we have none to give. As a musician myself, I have found that sometimes only music can suffice when feelings are raw and there is no way to describe what is welling up inside of me. Bruce Cockburn is one of my most favorite singer/songwriters. He has a way of weaving poetry, music, and a powerful message into beautiful soundscapes that easily capture me and draw me in. The title of this post, as well as the subtitle of this blog, are both taken from titles of Bruce songs. His song “Pacing The Cage” (song and lyrics below) adequately describe where I find myself of late; pensive and wondering how to bring light into such darkness.
My wife and I have recently been watching “The Handmaid’s Tale” on Hulu; an adaption of the excellent and haunting novel by Margaret Atwood. With each episode I am struck by how disturbed my soul becomes, not at what I’m watching, necessarily, but more so by the thought that I can see this dystopian near future as a real possibility here, if certain ideologies and misguided zealots were to actually find themselves in places of great power. In fact, it has already happened in our past here in the United States, and in other cultures and countries under other names. It is puritanical religious legalism lived out in the real world. It is the result of a “pious” and ultra-fundamentalist religious misogyny. What disturbs me more is that I now see this very trend in many Christian circles, including in Eastern Orthodoxy where I am a member. There seems to be a growing fascination with so-called “ultra-traditionalist” teachings and an alarming trend towards returning to a puritanical religion. This includes the notion that women occupy a lesser “place” and simply serve a “biological purpose” and “proper role” in the context of Christian marriage and “life in Christ.” I cannot think of any more acrimonious religious bullshit. This is not Christianity…it is at best misguided piety and misunderstood scripture, and at worst an ideology of hatred for the divine feminine that leads to imbalance and lopsided living. This is not spirituality…it is religious excrement; skewed and dangerous theology, that when truly lived out, can easily become the reality that is The Handmaid’s Tale. If you have not read the novel or watched the show, I strongly recommend it. It is powerful in that it conveys a very uncomfortable truth, that most people of faith do not wish to discuss; that misogyny and male chauvinism are alive and well, and often doled out under the guise of “following scripture” and “living piously.”